Beware Yon Dragons

A regular running monologue of opinions and ideas from a "country priest".

This blog represents the personal opinions of Fr. Chori Jonathin Seraiah, and is not necessarily representative of the position of St. George Catholic Church, in Republic, Missouri, the Ordinariate of the Chair of St. Peter, Bishop Steven Lopes, or the Catholic Church as a whole.

Is AI Alive?

Nov. 10, 2026

I have made it clear numerous times that I do not appreciate Artificial Intelligence. No amount of argumentation can make me like it. I have heard all the things that it can do, and numerous people have told me that it really cannot make terminators or put us in a matrix to make us into batteries. Fine, they can believe that; I am still going to be cautious. Msgr. Robert Hugh Benson once wrote, "The agnostic position is certainly the soundest in all matters outside the deposit of faith". I wholeheartedly agree. I trust the revelation of God without doubt. Everyone and everything else gets a lesser level of trust.

In thinking about what bothers me the most about AI, I have come to a preliminary conclusion. It is not really that I am worried that machines are going to take over the world (though it makes for interesting science fiction). It is that so many people treat AI as though it were alive. Even our president wants to remove the term "artificial" and call it "super intelligence". Nope; not for me. I cannot do it. AI is a proper term, but I would not mind changing what it stands for. Instead of "artificial intelligence" it would help us all see it in a more balanced fashion if we started thinking of it as an, "awareness impersonator".

AI pretends to be aware, but it is not. It never breathed. It never was hungry. It never thought (it only computes). It never felt loss. It never was fearful. It never prayed. It never felt guilt. It might impersonate some of these things, but it is only computing things quickly in order to pretend to speak like a human. No one I know thinks that AI is alive, but many treat it like it is so. That is one of the greatest dangers, in my opinion.

Playing with a hand grenade might not be a sin, but it is really foolish. I cannot say that it is a sin to use AI (at least not yet), but I would venture that it appears to be heading down the road of foolishness. We are still in the experimental stages, and have not yet "ridden this thing around the block". Let us step carefully, and not give too much trust to things that we have not yet fully thought through. Let us protect our hearts and make sure that we do not fall into any kind of idolatrous behavior. God Himself is the only true super intelligence, and He has no competition.

Recent Posts