Beware Yon Dragons

A regular running monologue of opinions and ideas from a "country priest".

This blog represents the personal opinions of Fr. Chori Jonathin Seraiah, and is not necessarily representative of the position of St. George Catholic Church, in Republic, Missouri, the Ordinariate of the Chair of St. Peter, Bishop Steven Lopes, or the Catholic Church as a whole.

When You Assume...

Nov. 16, 2026

I read (ok, "skimmed quickly" might be a better term) an article recently by a Catholic author that I often (ok, "almost always" would definitely be a better term) disagree with. I read what he writes regularly because it is good for us to be challenged to make sure that we are being wise and fair. This time, it was not so much a disagreement that I had with him, as it was a problem with an assumption that he was making in the article. I will give him credit that he was trying to help struggling parishes to find life once again. The problem, however, was that he wrote the article with the apparent assumption that every Catholic parish in the world is dying, and he has the one and only answer that will help it.

I will not deny that there are many parishes that are dying, and in need of some help if they are going to survive for more than the next decade or so. I will also not deny that this is a serious issue for numerous dioceses throughout the world. I will even give the benefit of the doubt that what the author is suggesting might help (though I have reasons to doubt it will). To assume, however, that every parish is dying is a grave error. Furthermore, to assume that every parish that is dying is doing so for the same reason is another big error. I cannot speak to every situation, but there are parishes in the Catholic Church that are not dying (and they are not only found in the Ordinariate!).

Finally, the biggest issue I have with the author's "solution" to the "problem" is caused by his own assumption. If you assume that every parish in the world is dying, then you will fail to look at the parishes that are not dying to find out what they are doing right. Looking at thriving parishes might actually lead one to discover a true solution (oh, my!). It reminds me of the letter I got recently that made the presumption that 85% of those who go through our OCIA ("RCIA") program fall away from the church in a year (which is the national average). No, that is not what is happening at St. George. We are not perfect, but we are not losing people left and right, and we are not dying.

Sadly, many who are stuck in modernist parishes (almost all of which are dying) cannot see past their own experience and presume that everyone else is making the same foolish mistakes that they are. By God's grace we at St. George parish can rejoice that He is providing for us. We can seek to be faithful in the ways that the Church has always told us to live out our faith. We can avoid modern errors and goofy ideas, and pursue simple, traditional holiness. We can trust in the power of Christ and His resurrection, and refuse to trust ourselves or our gimmicks. We praise God that we are not dying, and trust that if we have life in our parish, it is because God has enabled us to obey Him in the traditional manner of the faith "once delivered" to the Saints.

Recent Posts